Organic v. Monsanto
More than 270,000 organic farmers are taking on corporate agriculture giant Monsanto in a lawsuit filed March 30. Led by the Organic Seed Growers and Trade Association, the family farmers are fighting for the right to keep a portion of the world food supply organic—and preemptively protecting themselves from accusations of stealing genetically modified seeds that drift on to their pristine crop fields.
Consumers are powerful. For more than a decade, a cultural shift has seen shoppers renounce the faster-fatter-bigger-cheaper mindset of factory farms, exposéd in the 2008 documentary Food, Inc. From heirloom tomatoes to heritage chickens, we want our food slow, sustainable, and local—healthy for the earth, healthy for animals, and healthy for our bodies.
But with patented seeds infiltrating the environment so fully, organic itself is at risk. Monsanto’s widely used Genuity® Roundup Ready® canola seed has already turned heirloom canola oil into an extinct species. The suing farmers are seeking to prevent similar contamination of organic corn, soybeans, and a host of other crops. What’s more, they’re seeking to prevent Monsanto from accusing them of unlawfully using the very seeds they’re trying to avoid.
“It seems quite perverse that an organic farmer contaminated by transgenic seed could be accused of patent infringement,” says Public Patent Foundation director Dan Ravicher in a Cornucopia Institute article about the farmers’ lawsuit (May 30, 2011), “but Monsanto has made such accusations before and is notorious for having sued hundreds of farmers for patent infringement.”
Even as the megacorporation enjoys soaring stock, the U.S. justice department continues to look into allegations of its fraudulent antitrust practices (The Street, June 29, 2011):
Monsanto, which has acquired more than 20 of the nation’s biggest seed producers and sellers over the last decade, has long pursued a strict policy with its customers, obligating them to buy its bioengineered seeds every year rather than use them in multiple planting seasons. Farmers who disobey are blacklisted forever.
It’s a wide net Monsanto has cast over the agricultural landscape. As Ravicher points out, “it’s actually in Monsanto’s financial interest to eliminate organic seed so that they can have a total monopoly over our food supply.”
Imagine a world devoid of naturally vigorous traditional crops and controlled by a single business with a appetite for intellectual property. Did anyone else feel a cold wind pass through them? Now imagine a world where thousands of family farmers fight the good fight to continue giving consumers a choice in their food—and win.
via Organic v. Monsanto – Environment – Utne Reader.
Thanks to Charles Councill for this story.
August 13, 2011 Update from OSGATA
Farmers Defend Right to Protect Themselves From Monsanto Patents
Organizations File Amici to Defend Plaintiffs’ Right to Trial and Respond to Monsanto’s Attempt to Dismiss Case
New York – August 11, 2011 – The 83 family farmers, small and family owned seed businesses, and agricultural organizations challenging Monsanto’s patents on genetically modified seed filed papers in federal court today defending their right to seek legal protection from the threat of being sued by Monsanto for patent infringement should they ever become contaminated by Monsanto’s genetically modified seed. The Public Patent Foundation (PUBPAT) represents the plaintiffs in the suit, titled Organic Seed Growers & Trade Association(OSGATA), et al. v. Monsanto and pending in the Southern District of New York. Today’s filings respond to a motion filed by Monsanto in mid-July to have the case dismissed. In support of the plantiffs’ right to bring the case, 12 agricultural organizations also filed a friend-of-the-court amici brief.
“Rather than give a straight forward answer on whether they would sue our clients for patent infringement if they are ever contaminated by Monsanto’s transgenic seed, Monsanto has instead chosen to try to deny our clients the right to receive legal protection from the courts,” said Dan Ravicher, PUBPAT’s Executive Director. “Today’s filings include sworn statements by several of the plaintiffs themselves explaining to the court how the risk of contamination by transgenic seed is real and why they cannot trust Monsanto to not use an occurrence of contamination as a basis to accuse them of patent infringement.”
It is now virtually impossible for a U.S. farmer to grow crops of their choosing (corn, soybeans, canola, etc.) and remain GMO-free because of the numerous biological and human means by which seeds can spread. “Given the difficulties in minimizing GM contamination farmers must make numerous decisions about which steps are worthwhile for them and which steps are not. They are not able to make these decisions based on their own and their customers‘ interests, but must instead make these decisions with the threat of litigation from a giant corporation looming over their head,” Spiegel writes in the amici brief. “The constant threat of a patent infringement suit by Monsanto creates significant, unquantifiable costs for Plaintiff farmers and similarly situated farmers.” The plaintiffs can do everything possible to maintain non-contaminated seeds, and will very likely still become contaminated, and be placed under the threat of a lawsuit. As Monsanto’s domination of the seed industry grows, and the winds continue to disperse pollen from their GMO laced crops, the likelihood of contamination and lawsuits only increases.
Monsanto has stated that they would not sue farmers who were “inadvertently” contaminated or farmers whose crops contain “trace amounts” of GMO, however they have refused to sign a simple covenant not to sue, that would bring an effective end to the lawsuit.
Monsanto’s track record makes it clear that Monsanto intends to continue threatening and harassing farmers. “Monsanto has undertaken one of the most aggressive patent assertion campaigns in history,” wrote Ravicher. Monsanto admits to filing 128 lawsuits against farmers from 1997-2010, settling out of court with 700 others for an undisclosed amount. As Spiegel writes, “The passage of time and natural biological processes will inevitably lead to higher contamination levels, at which point Monsanto will have created a target-rich environment for its patent enforcement activities.”
Plaintiffs Bryce Stephens, who farms in Kansas and serves as vice president of OSGATA, Frederick Kirschenmann, who farms in North Dakota, C.R. Lawn, who is founder and co-owner of Fedco Seeds in Maine, Don Patterson of Virginia and Chuck Noble, who farms in South Dakota, each submitted declarations to the court describing their personal experiences with the risk of contamination by genetically modified seed and why those experiences have forced them to bring the current suit. As summarized by the accompanying brief filed by PUBPAT on the plaintiffs’ behalf, “Monsanto’s acts of widespread patent assertion and the plaintiffs’ ever growing risk of contamination create a real, immediate and substantial dispute between them.”
In their brief, the amici describe some of the harmful effects of genetically modified seed and how easily GMOs can contaminate an organic or conventional farmer’s land. The organizations filing the amici brief were Farm and Ranch Freedom Alliance, Biodynamic Farming and Gardening Association, Carolina Farm Stewardship Association, Ecological Farmers of Ontario, Fair Food Matters, International Organic Inspectors Association, Michigan Land Trustees, Natural Environment Ecological Management, Nebraska Sustainable Agriculture Association, Organic Council of Ontario, Slow Food USA, and Virginia Independent Consumers and Farmers Association.The brief filed by the plaintiffs in opposition to Monsanto’s motion to dismiss is available here.The amici brief in support of the plaintiffs is available here.Update via ORGANIC SEED GROWERS AND TRADE ORGANIZATION
270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto
Trackbacks and Pingbacks:
- Passive energy conversion | Nomad Gardens - save the world ~ one tree at a time - Pingback on 2013/11/26/ 21:50
- Non-GMO Shopping Guide | Glow Acupuncture & Wellness Center - Pingback on 2013/09/06/ 14:12
- Four Maine Farmers Head to D.C. to Challenge Monsanto in Court| Grow Switch News Blog | - Pingback on 2013/02/05/ 07:23
- Appeal set for January in 270,000 Organic Farmers vs. MonsantoGrow Switch News Blog - Pingback on 2012/11/23/ 15:39
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto | worldwide hippies - Pingback on 2012/11/07/ 00:35
- 360 Degree View | honiebriggs - Pingback on 2012/09/08/ 09:58
- Admiral Heemi Hau (heemi) | Pearltrees - Pingback on 2012/03/05/ 01:44
- FrankenCorn, Monsanto’s GM Corn Sold at Walmart | Downtown Local - Pingback on 2012/02/28/ 00:56
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto - Pingback on 2012/01/26/ 11:08
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto | Commodities, Resource and Freedom | Scoop.it - Pingback on 2012/01/10/ 08:32
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto | Sustainable Living | Scoop.it - Pingback on 2012/01/09/ 21:41
- Will Organic Farmers See Their Day in Court? | Grow Switch Blog - Pingback on 2011/12/31/ 13:23
- Economic Analysis Reveals Organic Farming Profitable Long-Term | Innovation Toronto - Pingback on 2011/09/27/ 16:57
- Monsanto's Michael Taylor is the second highest-ranking official at the FDA, Food Safety Czar | IndiePundit.com - Pingback on 2011/09/07/ 20:58
- Shaken, not stirred « Making Sense with Don L - Pingback on 2011/08/29/ 21:12
- Conscious Media Network » August 2011 - Pingback on 2011/08/23/ 00:19
- Organic Seed Growers File Lawsuit Against Agribusiness Giant Monsanto « My Writerly Ways - Pingback on 2011/08/21/ 13:39
- Coolmeia – 270.000 agricultores orgânicos vão a justiça contra a Monsanto « Jornada Contra os Agrotóxicos – DF - Pingback on 2011/08/19/ 07:33
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto | Stonington Farmers Market - Pingback on 2011/08/18/ 16:37
- RLM News - August 18th, 2011 | Real Liberty Media - Pingback on 2011/08/18/ 11:48
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto | The P2P Daily | Scoop.it - Pingback on 2011/08/17/ 19:50
- Over 270,000 Organic Farmers are Suing Monsanto | Daily News Blog - Pingback on 2011/08/17/ 10:53
- Over 270,000 Organic Farmers are Suing Monsanto | Daily News Blog - Pingback on 2011/08/17/ 10:53
- swale « Unabashed Thoughtcrime - Pingback on 2011/08/16/ 11:15
- 270.000 agricultores orgánicos demandan a Monsanto [ENG] | Noticias HMX - Pingback on 2011/08/16/ 10:15
- 270.000 agricultores orgánicos demandan a Monsanto [ENG] | Grace To You - Pingback on 2011/08/16/ 08:02
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto | Monica's PerFit Lifestyle - Pingback on 2011/08/16/ 02:18
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto « Netcrema – creme de la social news via digg + delicious + stumpleupon + reddit - Pingback on 2011/08/15/ 23:18
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto at SatelliteHeadlines.com - Pingback on 2011/08/15/ 20:15
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto | Health & Nutrition | Scoop.it - Pingback on 2011/08/15/ 09:31
- 270,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto « Zeke's Code 13 - Pingback on 2011/08/14/ 21:59